Blockstream researchers publish SHRINCS security analysis and seek feedback

  • Jonas Nick
  • Mikhail Kudinov
  • Blockstream
  • SHRINCS
  • Bitcoin

The Bitcoin signature proposal remains a draft BIP

Signatures range from 548 to 5,777 bytes

Blockstream Research Director Jonas Nick and researcher Mikhail Kudinov published a security analysis on November 19, 2026, for SHRINCS, a hash-based post-quantum signature proposal for Bitcoin, and requested feedback from the developer community.

SHRINCS is built on SHA-256, a cryptographic hash function already used by Bitcoin, and combines a stateful signing path with a stateless fallback path. Stateful signatures range from 548 to 4,619 bytes, while stateless signatures are 5,777 bytes, compared with approximately 71 bytes for current Bitcoin ECDSA signatures and 64 bytes for Taproot Schnorr signatures.

The stateful path relies on one-time keys that can safely sign only one transaction, meaning accidental reuse could allow an attacker to forge a signature and steal funds, according to Nick. To prevent user errors, the researchers recommend that wallet software automatically fall back to the stateless path whenever a state counter might be compromised, though Nick warned that widespread use of larger stateless signatures could reduce the number of transactions per block and affect fees.

As of November 19, 2026, SHRINCS remains a draft Bitcoin Improvement Proposal, and the working group—which includes researchers supported by Brink and OpenSats—is continuing to refine the specification. Kudinov said the draft needs review from engineers, cryptographers, and protocol developers, while the sources do not establish whether or when Bitcoin stakeholders will adopt the proposal.

Key terms explained

Bitcoin Improvement Proposal

A Bitcoin Improvement Proposal is a design document providing information to the Bitcoin community or describing a new feature for the Bitcoin protocol. It serves as a standardized way to propose changes and document technical decisions for the network.

stateful signing

Stateful signing is a method of digital signature generation that requires the signer to maintain a record of previously used keys to prevent reuse. If a key is used more than once, it can compromise the security of the signature and allow unauthorized parties to forge it.

Think of it this way. It is like using a checkbook where you must track the serial numbers of every check written; if you write two checks with the same number, the bank may reject them or allow fraud.